NC NAACP v. Hirsch – Decision

134-page trial decision by Senior U.S. District Judge Loretta C. Biggs in NC NAACP v. Hirsch, the continuation of the photo voter ID litigation. After full trial, the court entered judgment in favor of defendants on all claims, finding that under the Supreme Court's evolving standards in Brnovich, plaintiffs' evidence was insufficient to establish violations of the VRA or the Constitution.